Three Young Indiana Sisters Found Dead at Home – Their Heartbroken Father Speaks Out

In a tragic and heart-wrenching event, police found the bodies of a mother and her three young daughters in their Wolcottville home, sending shockwaves through the close-knit community. Investigations are ongoing, while the girls’ father, Jonathan Newell, has spoken out about the unimaginable loss that has shattered his family.

On September 17, Wolcottville Police responded to a welfare check at a residence on South Main Street after concerns were raised about the family’s well-being. Arriving around 11:20 a.m., officers made the devastating discovery: 32-year-old Rebecca Hughes and her daughters, Evalynn, 8, Allison, 6, and Amelia Newell, 5, all deceased.

The Indiana State Police quickly took over the investigation. Autopsies are being conducted, but authorities have yet to release the results, including pending toxicology reports. Despite the lack of concrete details, police have reassured the public that there is no immediate threat to the community.

Jonathan Newell, the girls’ father, shared his heartbreak and disbelief over the tragedy. Initially, he suspected Rebecca might have left with the children, but the grim reality that unfolded was far more devastating. In an emotional interview, Jonathan spoke of the anguish he’s been experiencing, recalling the uncertainty and dread leading up to the moment he received the horrific news. On the day of the tragedy, he was jolted awake by a frantic call from his mother, followed by distressing posts on social media that confirmed his worst fears.

When two officers arrived at his door to deliver the unthinkable news, Jonathan was consumed by shock and disbelief. As he processes his grief, he is overwhelmed by waves of anger, sorrow, and guilt, plagued by “what-ifs” and wondering if anything could have been done to change the outcome. “I feel like there’s a lot that can be blamed on me,” he said, reflecting on the helplessness and regret that now haunt him.

The small town of Wolcottville is reeling from the loss. A memorial has sprung up outside the family’s home, with flowers, stuffed animals, and heartfelt messages left by grieving neighbors and friends. The outpouring of love from the community is palpable. Pam Laughlin, a fellow church member, tearfully remembered the girls, and neighbor Greg Williams, still in shock, recalled seeing Rebecca just days before the tragedy.

In the midst of his pain, Jonathan has been met with an overwhelming wave of support. A GoFundMe campaign has raised over $45,000 to help him honor his daughters with the farewell they deserve. Touched by the generosity of strangers, Jonathan expressed his deep gratitude, saying, “This is the last thing I can do for them.”

As the community mourns, a close friend of Rebecca’s, Ashley McAtee, took to social media to share insight into Rebecca’s struggles. Ashley described her as a loving mother who likely faced mental and emotional battles without enough support. “Rebecca loved her kids,” Ashley wrote, urging others not to rush to judgment.

Now, Jonathan is using his platform to raise awareness about the importance of mental health. He encourages parents who are struggling to seek help, emphasizing that mental health support is crucial for both parents and children. “You never know when it’s going to be the last time you can,” he said, underscoring the urgency of finding help before it’s too late.

As the investigation continues, the community stands united in grief, offering Jonathan support and waiting for answers that might bring some understanding to this heartbreaking loss.